That money mentality

that money mentality

<image via 68751915@N05 on flickr>

A couple of posts recently about debt, poverty and money management have  spurred me to revisit this post I started some time ago and bring together various threads I’ve been reflecting on of late. I think, especially if you’re from a comfortable background, it’s difficult to understand what vastly different lives some people lead – I know it was for me, but after having observed one of these families up close, I wanted to share my observations.

It’s weird being 18, and a student, and yet being asked (and able to) lend money to an older grown adult. It’s weird being 22 and ferrying those people around, because they have no access to a car. (True stories).

What is the difference between a person who lives in overdraft week-to-week and someone with a surplus? Why are some people savvy with finances and some are not? Is it instinct?

I grew up being taught to always save (not for anything in particular, but for the sake of it), saving all the money from my paper route, and having my parents also pitch in. I had money invested for me. “We can’t afford it” meant “It’s not in the budget” or “I’m not spending that much on ___”, not “We literally do not have the money for it.”

It was an eye-opener to be introduced to a way of life where:

– jobs are more common than careers, yet still not as common as welfare

– you’re always short a few dollars

– everyone in the family has bad credit

– nobody knows how to check their credit reports

– nobody has a savings account

– you pay the same amount toward their power bill every week because it’s easier than figuring out how to pay it at the end of the month

– everything is bought on hire purchase

It’s about the way you’re brought up.  Is it any wonder that when someone from a background like this gets their first job, they go out and spend it all? Maybe give a little to their family to help out with essentials. Buy the things you need to get started in life (but probably not at the best prices), plus the things you may have wanted before but couldn’t afford.

You know nothing else. Kids don’t talk about money, after all. What do they know about it? And they don’t teach personal finance in school. There are no role models for success. Maybe the first you hear of another way of life is when you get to be 20-something and hear of others taking overseas trips and buying reliable cars – all through the power of savings. Of TVs bought with cash, not on tick. Of daring to have dreams, within reach.

And it goes hand in hand with values and a general way of life. One where education and reading are not necessarily prized. Where it’s going to be entirely up to you to break the cycle.

There is a fabulous comment on this One Dollar Diet Project post I wish to quote:

“I know that it’s ridiculously hard to get out of a situation if no one has ever taught you that it’s important or possible. It’s hard to save any money or advance at all when there are friends and family around you who are not; so you share when you have money or goods, and they share when you can’t, and no one ever gets enough to advance because it’s better for all to have some, rather than one to have all. And if no one is there to teach or set an example, saying “If you’re selfish for a little while, and you keep your successes for yourself and move up, then you can truly share with others.” 

This is very true. At least from what I’ve observed, it’s about communal spirit, and sharing everything (what little?) they have. Family member needs something? If someone else can help out, then damn straight they will.  Everyone pitches in. But if you’re sharing everyone’s successes subsequently no one ever really does spectacularly well because it gets spread around. (Perhaps another example of tall poppy syndrome, which we so love to trot out in NZ?)

“Too many times it’s lack of the basic necessities that keep the poor poor. Housing, medical care, food, education, child care, transportation: how do you choose which ones are a priority, or are you even given the choice?”

And then of course, getting out of that cycle takes incredible individual drive, and it takes education (if you haven’t checked out PlaySpent, you should – I’ve never had to make any of the tough choices posed there, and I can’t imagine being truly faced with them). Though I would like to note here another observation – of the immense importance placed on birthdays and Christmas. No matter what, the kids always get presents, and LOTS of them. Personally, I think that’s commendable, but shouldn’t be a priority if you’re not otherwise stable. I didn’t get presents at birthdays and Christmas – even though my parents could afford them – and I turned out fine, I think…

It was difficult enough for me to figure out the best way to manage my money at the age of what, 20? And that’s without even having come out of a debt-ridden or shopaholic phase. It was easy enough when it was just me, in high school – while my income was ridiculously low so were my expenses. Then T and I moved in together: cue more income, bigger expenses and a more complex budget. I would venture a comparison to trying to lose weight, or dieting – something countless people have tried and failed at time and time again.

How do you do it at 25, 30, 40 – and coming from an ingrained background of living hand-to-mouth? And what if you’re not – sorry, this is probably not quite the right word – intellectually inclined? When all you have outside of work is knocking back beers, and you’ve been doing it for as long as you remember – are you really going to start taking an interest in spreadsheets and number crunching?

I don’t mean to say that it’s hopeless, or inescapable. Far from it. I know some of you know all this already having lived it yourselves, but for the rest of us, I’m just seeking to offer some insight into a different mindset – and why in theory it seems there’s no excuse to be broke, it’s not as easy as we’d like to think. I truly believe it can’t be understood unless seen firsthand.

Even though my fiance and I are the same age financially I am far better off – and that’s partly due to bad decisions on his part, but also a run of bad luck. (I’d say the number of incidents are about even – but I won’t list them in detail as it’s really not my place).

You’ve heard me talk about how fundamentally I’m the saver and he’s the spender enough times; well, the only consumer debt he’s ever actually had was a small car loan. The vast majority of his debt was not incurred by him, but he was stuck with it. (Again, probably not my prerogative to explain). He’s never even had a credit card of his own. I can understand why he might feel bitter about money and even life in general, sometimes. To me, there is no better personified example of what upbringing + lack of education/knowhow + a couple of unfortunate setbacks courtesy of fate can yield – and how having a financial role model/coach can help turn things around.

It’s strange being 22 and better off than all of your folks. It can be a great source of guilt, when they’re essentially good people trapped by a cocktail of bad luck, circumstance and poor choices.

But guilt is a useless emotion. Good people don’t have to be broke to be good. You only get one life, and if you don’t put yourself first, getting sucked back under will make it that much harder to climb out again.

17 thoughts on “That money mentality

  • Reply The Everyday Minimalist April 19, 2011 at 10:14

    What an amazing, soulful post. I’m linking to this tomorrow on the FB Blog. Everyone should be made to read this.

  • Reply Clare - Never Niche April 19, 2011 at 11:19

    I couldn’t agree more.

  • Reply Annie April 19, 2011 at 11:53

    I grew up in the life of “Not enough” where you wonder where the money will come for every bill. I married further into that life and then left it when I divorced. I’m living rather tight now but it is by choice right now to make life better instead of a constant circumstance. For so many it is. Just. Life. My sister lives like that. She has to decide every month which bills to pay to keep everything on, not including how to pay for other things.

    Some things you just accept for what they are, you know?

  • Reply First Gen American April 20, 2011 at 08:03

    It’s not just role models and your environment though. My cousins and I were both raised in frugal, borderline miserly homes. I see a dramatic difference in the way we operate. Laziness and/or being too good/busy to work is such a horrible handicap that has led to decades of lost income for them.

    I’m the exact opposite. I’ve had a job pretty much non-stop since I qualified for a work permit at age 14, but even babysat regularly since 11. I’m not sure that’s healthy either, but it’s interesting how two similar backgrounds yielded polar opposite results.

    • Reply eemusings April 20, 2011 at 10:04

      Individual drive/ability goes without saying. It’s never impossible to overcome your upbringing.

  • Reply Link Love from Around The Globe April 20, 2011 at 22:00

    […] wrote a thoughtful post called That money mentality blew me […]

  • Reply Kelly April 21, 2011 at 01:41

    Very interesting post. Since getting married (or being in this relationship) I’ve noticed how much upbringing can affect how people manage finances. My husband’s family is much more about spending what they have and if they don’t have it, they are fine with putting it on a credit card. In my house, things were put on a credit card only to be paid in fully each month. I can’t stand giving credit card companies my money, and he sees it as no big deal. Fortunately both of us had “enough” as kids. It’s even more fascinating to see those that did not and how they deal with it.

    I’ve heard a lot about the kids getting presents on Christmas and birthdays. I think maybe 1 present each kid would be good. It’s nice that it’s a priority to have the kids be happy but on the other hand, it should be a priority that the kids have the basic things they need.

  • Reply Lindsay April 21, 2011 at 15:01

    I grew up in a family where we lived paycheck to paycheck and were never taught anything about budgeting or money except that it causes stress.

    I have student loan debt and I *used* to have credit card debt. But I don’t now. Thanks to personal finance blogs and a desire to better my life and have financial freedom, I’m now debt-free and have savings. I’m the ONLY person in my family with a savings account (that includes young & old). Sad, but true.

  • Reply Making your way in the white collar world | Musings of an Abstract Aucklander May 31, 2011 at 15:13

    […] in class and social issues. Like I said, while I’m of a white-collar upbringing, for me class and culture intersect to affect who I am […]

  • Reply It all started with an iPhone (Or, why mixing family and money only leads to dramas) | Musings of an Abstract Aucklander June 30, 2011 at 12:19

    […] T is increasingly getting frustrated with his sister, and has had strong words to her more than once recently, apparently telling her that enough is enough from him after this latest debacle. It is hard when there are kids involved. And of course they will always be taken care of. But ultimately nobody will put us first except, well, us. […]

  • Reply Playing poor | Musings of an Abstract Aucklander July 13, 2011 at 11:46

    […] For another, it’s simply not logistically viable. We have a car. We go on the odd holiday (in fact, just returned from our first trip abroad together). We have gadgets (Xbox, smartphones, digital cameras). We even go to concerts from time to time. This is all pretty obvious. If we’re not a total mess, then we are already miles ahead. Trust me when I say the bell curve in this case is rather low. […]

  • Reply Seven Links | Musings of an Abstract Aucklander July 30, 2011 at 08:47

    […] did get quite a bit of reaction to That money mentality, but not as much as I anticipated. I think that’s because a) I don’t have a hardcore PF […]

  • Reply When your significant other’s family is a financial mess | Musings of an Abstract Aucklander October 21, 2011 at 18:10

    […] covered this ground so many […]

  • Reply Link love (Powered by interns and hunger pangs) | Musings of an Abstract Aucklander December 17, 2011 at 09:12

    […] everything I tried to say here, but far more […]

  • Reply Link love (Powered by houseguests and popcorn) | Musings of an Abstract Aucklander January 29, 2012 at 09:46

    […] At Cracked, five stupid habits that growing up poor engenders (echoes my post here). […]

  • Reply Link love (Powered by faulty tech and early dawns) | Musings of an Abstract Aucklander April 7, 2012 at 12:09

    […] year ago I ran my first 10k, pondered a certain money mindset I’ve observed among the perennially broke and mused on the great balancing act of […]

  • Reply The two things you need to successfully change your life | NZ Muse October 17, 2012 at 19:03

    […] weekend. His professors visited him in jail so he could complete his course criteria. It’s something I’ve mentioned before – you need incredible inner strength and motivation to break a cycle, and it’s damn […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *